An Easy and Foolproof Way to Make the Best Yogurt at Home

Your best yogurt can be made at home, you know why? Because you can make it in the most healthy and non-toxic way! The commercial prepared store bought version of yogurt pales in comparison to the taste, thickness and flavor offered by homemade yogurt in this method that we are about to teach you! And of course this is achieved without the use of artificial thickeners, pectin, and whatnot. Also, you can forget about getting your food close to plastic (most store bought yogurt are prepared and come in toxic plastic containers). So, without further ado, let us dive into the best way of making yogurt that has been practiced from time immemorial.

How to Make Yogurt at Home: A Quick and Easy Recipe, with Tips on Making it Thick and Delicious

This is a different & easy, time-honored, and people-beloved method of making thick, creamy & healthy yogurt each time. Our ancestors relied on clay pots for making yogurt years ago, and it is the best way to make yogurt even today. There is no need for electronic appliances or artificial thickeners/sweeteners – all you need is 1/2 a gallon or less of raw or pasteurized milk, some leftover yogurt as a starter (see notes), and an MEC 100% non-toxic pot. Then follow these steps:

(3 steps, 7-10 minutes hands-on time)

Ingredients: Raw or pasteurized milk & live yogurt culture (2-3 Tbsp. of yogurt from the previous batch per every 1/2 gallon of milk)

Step 1:

Heat ½ gallon of milk to just before boiling point (till small bubbles form on the surface). Turn stove off, and open lid and let it cool down for 30 mins or so, till you can put your little finger and hold it there for 5 secs. Now the milk is ready for the culture.

Boiling Milk
Boiling Milk in MEC

Step 2:

Add yogurt culture, stir thoroughly.

Step 3:

Set in the oven with the lid on and oven light on. Let it incubate for 6-8 hours and the yogurt is ready!

Freshly Finished Yogurt in MEC


  • While Set of 2 | Yogurt Maker is our best seller for making yogurt and each pot can make a little over 1/2 gallon, the other pots can also be used for making bigger batches. The MEC large pot can make 1 gallon and the x-large pot can make 1.5 gallons.
  • Use the pot with the diffuser, especially when cooking on any stove that runs on electricity—glass, ceramic, or coil cook-tops.
  • Yogurt from whole milk is best because it is less manipulated and has most of the original nutrients. However, you can also use low-fat if you prefer. The fat in whole milk is essential for brain cell growth and nourishment for people of all ages.
  • In a few uses, the milk will take less time to get hot than in a new pot.

Why is Making Yogurt At Home Is The Best Option?

A lot of the good stuff in yogurt is processed out in the store bought yogurt. It is usually loaded with unhealthy sugars and artificial sweeteners. A number of other additives and artificial thickeners (pectin, gelatin, vegetable shortening, etc.) make it unhealthy. Also, yogurt is heat processed to increase shelf life, which can destroy live bacterial cultures. As a result, store-bought yogurt is unfortunately anything but healthy. 

There are many different healthy homemade flavors you can add to your yogurt, here are some of our favorites:

  • Yogurt with brown sugar, a pinch of salt, and chopped almonds and walnuts
  • Yogurt with pureed fruits—try blueberries or strawberries with nuts of your choice
  • Yogurt with granola is also another healthy choice for breakfast

If you like it with some heat: go for yogurt with chopped cilantro, thinly sliced onions and some chopped green chilies with a pinch of sea salt. This recipe for yogurt turns out best if you add about 3-4 Tbsp. of water to every cup of yogurt. You do not have to use exact measurements, however. Just make sure the yogurt is not too thick! Dilute it to a thick but pourable (flowing) consistency.

The internet is a good source for things you can make with your yogurt, but remember to use recipes that do not call for the use of any artificial or unhealthy ingredients or chemicals!

The Benefits Of Healthy Homemade Yogurt

Your yogurt is a good source of many minerals needed to stay healthy. It is high in zinc. Zinc is important for cell growth and repair. One eight-oz. serving has around 42 percent of your daily calcium, a crucial aspect of healthy bones.

Also, yogurt has a high amount of phosphorus. Phosphorus works with calcium to help with bone strength and growth. Natural yogurt also has 15 percent of your daily value of potassium that helps to keep your muscles working properly…

Your homemade yogurt is also a great source of multiple B vitamins like Riboflavin or Vitamin B2, B8, B1, and B5. It is also a rich source of Thiamin and Foliate.

How Does MEC’s Homemade Yogurt Compare to Greek Yogurt and Others?

Compared to regular plain yogurt made without thickeners or additives, MEC’s homemade yogurt is very different. It is clearly much thicker and creamier and delicious. When compared to Greek-style yogurt, MEC’s is thicker and healthier, because Greek yogurt is thickened by straining the yogurt several times and discarding the essential liquid probiotics. 

With MEC’s homemade yogurt, the liquid and the semi-solid probiotics stay intact while the pot slowly and naturally lets just the water evaporate.

On a side note: Did you know the Greeks actually made their yogurt in clay pots, and that’s why it turned out thick? People tried to imitate that and came up with the process of “straining”.

Besides being thicker and creamier, your yogurt made in MEC pots is without a doubt healthier because the food has no interaction with metals or chemicals. It also does not experience nutritional loss while cooking or heating.

Making Yogurt with Non-Dairy Milk

One may use non-dairy milk as well, but the bacterial cultures that can ferment non-dairy milk are different. The species Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus bacteria are used to culture dairy milk into yogurt.

Plant-based milks like soy milk, coconut milk, or almond milk require species such as Lactobacillus caseiLactobacillus rhamnosus, and Bifidobacterium bifidum to ferment.

Now that we understand the science of making yogurt, the next important step is choosing the right pot. Keep reading to discover how.

People Also Ask:

What are the main ingredients of yogurt?

The main ingredients of yogurt are milk and starter culture. The milk can be raw milk or pasteurized milk, and dairy or plant-based.

Is making your own yogurt worth it?

Definitely! The heavy processing of store bought yogurt combined with unhealthy additives like preservatives, thickeners, artificial flavors, and sweeteners render it unhealthy, as almost all the good stuff is processed out.

Making your own yogurt avoids all that, and it is way more nutritious because of all the probiotics intact.

How do you make homemade yogurt culture from scratch?

You can make yogurt culture or starter at home from whole milk and any one among lemon, fresh chili or cardamom pods.

Just boil the milk, cool it down and pour it in a small bowl. Then add chili (with stem), or cut one side of lemon and dip in the milk (do not squeeze the juice out), or break one large cardamom pod in half and submerge both halves in milk. Half-cover the bowl and leave it in a warm place until it thickens (15-20 hours). Your primary yogurt culture is ready.

You may use leftovers from previous batches of culture for making subsequent batches.


Published by

Sachin Sharma

I hail from a small but popular city of India known as Kurukshetra, mentioned numberless times in Indian/Hindu mythology because of some amazing historical events that supposedly took place there. I have done B.Tech in Information Technology but I decided not to be a Software Engineer as my qualification would have me be because it was all such a cliché. I love to live like a free spirit and do whatever I feel like doing at any moment. I have tried to work in multiple fields but none of them was interesting enough to keep me tied-up for too long. I am a typical Freelancer. I know I am destined to achieve greatness but when and how, I don't know yet.

One thought on “An Easy and Foolproof Way to Make the Best Yogurt at Home”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s